Gary Giddins, the excellent jazz critic and biographer of Bing Crosby, has an op-ed piece in today’s New York Times on what he considers the story of the year: the lip-sync scandals. Ashlee Simpson, Lindsay Lohan, Britney Spears, Luciano Pavarotti, Shania Twain, Beyoncé, Madonna: such is Giddins’ list of shame.
Giddins is no prude however. His essay, “Put Your Voice Where Your Mouth Is,” gives the kind of sensible, historical perspective you’d expect from Giddins. The sky isn’t falling. It dropped to earth long ago, and some people even prefer it that way. Do you really want to hear what Britney sounds like when she’s gyrating out there? Cue the digital sound.
Which brings me back to a theme about the stuff that happens on the Powell Hall stage each week. What you see and hear is what you get – an unfiltered, undigitized, unmediated experience. And that is becoming a rare thing, I daresay verging on extinction. David Halen’s string breaks in the middle of the Mahler Seven. Peter Otto hands Halen his own violin so the concertmaster can play as Otto quickly restrings Halen’s instrument. That happened, and it was as much a part of the performance as the glorious sound that rang in my head all the way home.
Things happen. Musicians have different insights, hear different harmonies on stage and change intonation or blend in a way that hasn’t been done in rehearsal, or in the performance the night before. It really is the intersection of art and life. It’s a thrill.
I will be away until Tuesday, the fourth day of 2005. A happy New Year to you. I’ll be at the concert Friday night, and I’ll write what I can remember on Tuesday. It is New Year’s after all.

